Help PMA grow | Petition forms | Site map | PMA main page
Action Alert - SIS - Submissions due!
Peace Movement AotearoaPO Box 9314, Wellington. Tel (04) 382 8129, fax (04) 382 8173, firstname.lastname@example.org
Issued 29 April 1999
SIS Amendment Bill 2 - submissions due soon !
Kia ora, this alert will be sent in two parts :
a) some comments on the SIS Amendment Bill 2 (AB2) and details of where to send your submissions - note the deadline is 7 MAY 1999;
b) the emailable version of AB2.
AB2 - more security or less ?
There has been some publicity given to the AB2, which the government says incorporates changes made by those giving submissions on the SIS Amendment Bill 1 which has recently passed into law. However, AB2 appears to be comprised of cosmetic changes only, the key point made by many submissions - that the Security Intelligence Service should be open to public scrutiny - has been entirely ignored.
The major changes in AB2 relate to:
i) definition of security - security has been redefined as follows :
This section then goes on to say ...
Linked to this is the fact that the complaints procedure for looking into dodgy SIS practices proved worthless in the case of that break-in. Following an investigation of the complaint, the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security made the statement that "the actions and procedures which affected the complainants directly or indirectly were lawful, reasonable and justified." A statement the court quite clearly disagreed with when ruling the break-in was illegal.
As the January 1999 Democratic Rights Defence Fund leaflet says ... In light of the contempt the SIS has shown for the law and the failure of the complaint procedures, the SIS should not be given extra powers but should be made more accountable.”
ii) differentiating between foreign and domestic interception warrants
As you may recall, the big problem with the SIS Amendment Bill 1 was the legalised right of home invasion by the SIS - for more information on that, see the “Do you want the SIS in your home ?’ alert (January 1999, stored on our website). AB2 still legalises home invasion but it has been superficially amended as follows. There will now be foreign interception warrants and domestic interception warrants, the former to be issued with the sole authorisation of the Prime Minister; the second to be signed jointly by the Prime Minister and a new Commissioner of Security Warrants (CSW) who will be a retired High Court judge. The functions, appointment etc of the CSW are outlined in AB2.
The problem with this of course, relates again to public scrutiny, as the CSW and Prime Minister can only act on information as provided by the SIS, there is no guarantee that the SIS will not manipulate the information provided to ensure the outcome they want - ie the issuing of a warrant.
Further, the addition of the signature of the CSW does not alter the fact that the new right of the SIS or agents acting for them to enter homes and/or offices and the homes and/or offices of friends, workmates, acquaintances etc of suspects and to remove ‘things’ (yes folks, that’s really what it says in the Bill) remains. Furthermore, having broken in once to seize ‘things’ and/or plant a ‘device’, AB2 seems to authorise further break-ins after an interception warrant has expired to remove the ‘device’.
The person/s who can carry out the break-ins, seize ‘things’ and install or remove ‘devices’ are not themselves specified in the Bill, although they do have to be specified in the warrant. However, the warrant may also request the assistance of “one or more persons or class of persons” ! Professional burglars ?
iii) free of political interference
There is a sub- section in AB2 which reads as follows :
Finally, there are various other changes in AB2. Click here for the full text of the New Zealand Security Intelligence Amendment Bill No. 2 - brace yourself as it is not light reading, then get your submission in !
Send your submission to the Intelligence and Security Committee - state on it whether or not you wish to make an oral submission to the committee (at this stage the Prime Minister's office is again saying that oral submissions will probably only be heard in Wellington, but if enough of you ask for them elsewhere then perhaps you will get your wish granted !).
Your submission should be sent to Margot Christeller, Intelligence and Security Committee, 5th Floor, Reserve Bank Building, Wellington or fax 04 473 2789 to reach her by 7 MAY 1999 at the latest. You are to send 25 copies of your submission if possible. If you have any enquiries about making your submission, you can telephone her on 04 471 9638.
Many thanks to David S and Christine G for assistance with this alert; any errors are not theirs.
Click here for the full text of New Zealand Security Intelligence Amendment Bill No. 2
Click here for further information on the SIS Bill.
Link to the main page on the SIS and spies.