NZ’s People Are Our Greatest Asset

Invest In Them As Top Priority

- by Murray Horton


This was commissioned by the online edition of the New Zealand Herald . It was published , with slight editing changes, on 15 January 2010 (online only, not in the hard copy edition). It was one of a series of opinion pieces from various people published under the heading “Catching Up With Australia”. The introduction to the series reads: “ Don Brash's 2025 Taskforce ( made a range of recommendations about how our economy could catch up with Australia. Its ideas, which included slashing Government spending, met with widespread condemnation. Murray Horton: Secretary/Organiser for the Campaign Against Foreign Control of Aotearoa (CAFCA) is one of a range of New Zealanders approached by to share their thoughts on how we can shorten the gap”.

The series can be accessed at My one attracted the most Comments, both strongly for and against. I must say that I think the whole subject of “catching up with Australia” is a non-issue and a sideshow. It’s not one that I would have voluntarily written about, but an invitation from NZ’s biggest paper is not one to be passed up, plus they were good enough to include a link to the CAFCA Website, putting a whole new audience in touch with us. There was a very low word limit (this article is at it), so I was constrained in what I could say in the space available. As for Brash’s Taskforce, its recommendations were immediately rejected by the Government as too extreme. MH.

Let’s leave aside the question of all the ways in which Australia presents a very undesirable model for New Zealand to follow. CAFCA’s issue is foreign control and the 2025 Taskforce includes in its Recommendations that “a much more liberal (foreign investment) regime should be introduced”. Here Australia does provide some positive guidelines – its Foreign Investment Review Board has the guts to, occasionally, put the national interest first and actually refuse some applications. For this it gets pilloried in the media as “obstructionist”. When was the last time that happened with our rubberstamp Overseas Investment Office? Australia has, or recently has had, restrictions on ownership of major sectors of its economy: banks, the media, airlines. NZ has let Australian airlines fly domestic NZ routes for years – but Australia is not silly enough to reciprocate, as Air New Zealand learnt the hard way. Australia has compulsory superannuation, meaning that it has built up a huge pool of funds available for investment. Australia still has awards* and stronger unions (despite the best attempts of successive governments to bust them). Most obviously, Australia pays better wages, which is the main reason that Kiwis flock there. * You have to remember NZ as it was before the since repealed 1991 Employment Contracts Act, to know what an award was. It’s all contracts now, but none of them have the national scope of the old awards. MH.

Put National Interest First, Last And Foremost

So, the way for NZ to catch up with Australia is to reverse the damage inflicted by a quarter of a century of relentless experimentation by our free market fundamentalists, the Taliban of capitalism. Restore decent wages and conditions; get rid of the legislative “architecture” of Rogernomics; restore the social safety net that has been shot full of holes; realise that the country’s greatest asset is its people and invest in them properly, in areas such as health and education; use superannuation and savings funds to invest in the rundown infrastructure and services of this country, not to play in the casino of the global financial system; end the obsessive compulsive urge to commodify, corporatise, privatise and monetise everything. Develop a foreign investment regime where the national interest is put first, last, and foremost. Introduce controls on capital movements into and out of the country. Emphasise that it us that are doing the favour to these foreign investors, not the other way around; they are guests in our home and must abide by our rules. And reinforce the point that New Zealanders must be the owners of our own country, not tenants in a branch economy.

None of this is “xenophobia” or “isolationism”. It is simply an assertion that New Zealand will engage with the world on our terms. It is the same principled self-interest that saw us go nuclear free and lay down our terms for engaging with the world’s most powerful country. The sky didn’t fall, and the world came to respect our right to do so. We’re still waiting for the world, and Australia, to catch up with us.

It takes a lot of work to compile and write the material presented on these pages - if you value the information, please send a donation to the address below to help us continue the work.

Foreign Control Watchdog, P O Box 2258, Christchurch, New Zealand/Aotearoa. May 2010.


Return to Watchdog 123 Index